Pinnacle Family Law
Family Law and Estate Planning. Offices in Novi, Ann Arbor, Lansing, Kalamazoo and Grand Rapids. Michigan Statewide Practice.
Free Consultation: 248-305-6484
Areas & Topics



If your spouse has an attorney who is a, well, you-know-what, chances are you have thought about all of the ways you can tell that attorney to go you-know-where. Whether it was in court, when you heard that attorney accuse you of being a "deadbeat" or an "absentee parent," or in a letter accusing you of hiding money and having to pay it back "or else" or in an attorneys' exchange outside the courtroom in which your attorney and your spouse's went at it yelling at each other in a battle more reminiscent of a dog fight, these kinds of exchanges can be unnerving.

More often than not, attorneys like your spouse's intend them to be unnerving. Clients who are worried about those threats (valid or not) coming true are more likely to settle outside of court, and their soon-to-be-ex's who need to feel vindicated in their divorce need (valid or not) to see their attorneys giving them a pit bull style show.

But this style of advocacy often has very little -if anything - to do with the merits of your case, like how good a parent you are, how much you support your family already and how your property should be divided fairly. So is the style appropriate? And what can you do if, or when, it crosses the line? Try the following --

It's Not Personal - First, keep in mind that it is not personally. Really. It may come across as personal when your spouse's attorney calls you this and that, but, more often than not, those are stock phrases that roll off the attorney's tongue with ease because that is the attorney's style. When your case is over, the attorney will probably not remember who you are and will go on to the next case using the same phrases against the next opponent. Your spouse's attorney does not know you, only what your spouse has said about you, which is obviously slated in his or her favor. Like it or not, when spouses divorce, yours sees herself as Mother Teresa and her husband as Manson. So, the next time you hear the attorney call you a "deadbeat," remind yourself that this attorney says that about everyone and has no idea who you really are. The judge, who has likely heard this attorney say the same thing in countless cases before yours, knows likewise.

Two Wrongs Won't Make a Right - Granted, that does not make the attorney's remarks fair. But it also does not give you and your attorney the freedom to stoop to their level, either. In this instance, as in many, to wrongs do not make a right. It is tempting to respond in kind with statements like your spouse is a liar, a cheater, and so-forth, but, trust me, your judge will tune out everything you and your attorney have to say and conclude both spouses are at fault for this divorce. That will translate to stricter trial deadlines, referrals for counseling, additional hearings, and more, all of which costs you time and money. And if you spouse makes less money than you, you could be paying his or her share, too. The better approach is to present yourself as humble, upstanding and courteous - even in the face of such pit bull style lawyering - to the judge. Your and your attorney's style will contrast with your spouse's, and that contract will actually amplify how outstanding, credible, and believable you are. In other words, you use that pit bull style to your advantage by not caving in but ignoring it.

Sanctions - But if (or when) that style crosses the line, you may want to sue. How can anyone, much less an attorney who is subjected to a code of ethics, get away with unsupported accusations and blatant lies, right? Unfortunately, in most jurisdictions, statements in courtrooms are absolutely protected from slander lawsuits. This means, you cannot sue the attorney, or your spouse for that matter, for making such statements in documents offered to the court or in oral argument to the judge. However, that does not mean your spouse and his or her attorney face no repercussions for their actions. In those same jurisdictions, laws usually provide that your judge can sanction your spouse, his or her attorney or both with fines, awards of attorneys fees and contempt punishment time for making statements that are: (1) materially false; or (2) unsupported by law or (3) not advanced as a reasonable extension of existing law. So, when these statements get out of hand, talk with your attorney about sanctions to get them under control - and, ideally, out of your case altogether.

Divorce is tough. But attorneys who argue for the sake of arguing only make it tougher, most often on your attorney fee dollar. If you are faced with this type of attorney on the opposite side of the courtroom, remind yourself of these three things - and never stoop to their level.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information


Novi Office
39555 Orchard Hill Place
Suite 600
Novi, MI 48375

Phone: 248-305-6484
Map & Directions

Grand Rapids Office
250 Monroe Avenue NW
Suite 400
Grand Rapids, MI 49504

Phone: 248-305-6484
Map & Directions

Lansing Office
120 North Washington Square
Suite 300
Lansing, MI 48933

Phone: 248-305-6484
Map & Directions

Kalamazoo Office
251 N Rose St.
Kalamazoo, MI 49007

Map & Directions

  • ICLE Contributor
  •  Legal Shield
  • Super Lawyers